More on the not-the-liver fallacy: medical, neuropsychological, and perceptual dissociations.
نویسنده
چکیده
«...You are in the audience of a well-attended medical conference, about to listen to the highly regarded Dr. Fright. ‘I have a new discovery’, Dr. Fright begins. ‘I have isolated the organ system which removes toxins from the blood – I call it the ‘liver’’. Amidst oohs and ahs, Dr Fright provides some evidence for his discovery: ‘when this organ is removed from a rat, toxins quickly build up, and the rat dies’. Applause from the crowd. ‘But that is not all’, the lecture continues, «I have discovered a second organ. This organ circulates the blood, absorbs nutrients, expels waste products from the body, and attacks foreign invaders.’ ‘For when the liver is removed’, he argues, ‘the body is still able to do all these things and more, until such time as the toxin buildup is fatal. I suggest we call this second organ ‘Not-the-Liver’...’» (Bedford, 1997, p. 231). This fictitious story illustrates an erroneous conclusion. There is no second «not the liver» organ. Rather, the evidence shows merely that the liver is not the only organ in the body. While in this context the conclusion is clearly absurd, I claim the same formal conclusion is drawn routinely about «mental organs» (cf. Gall, 1791; Chomsky, 1975) from dissociation data. The Not-the Liver fallacy (NTL) refers to the erroneous conclusion that what remains after damage must be a coherent category, process, module, or natural kind. One example involves the universally known partition of memory into explicit and implicit components (Schacter, 1987, 1992). Implicit memory is founded on the NTL fallacy (Bedford, 1997). Damage to hippocampal structures produces a deficit in the ability to intentionally retrieve recently presented information while sparing the ability to do so indirectly or implicitly. A patient might fail to recall any words from a study list, or even that there was a study list, but then is more likely to use words from that list in various free association tasks. The NTL draws attention to the fact that while explicit memory is dissociated from «other stuff», the dissociation provides no way to understand that amorphous other stuff. The patient can also navigate the environment, perform mathematical calculations, show classical and operant conditioning, adapt to prism-displaced vision and so on and so on. There is no evidence that what remains following selective removal of one function is a coherent and meaningful category. Analogous to the way in which removal of the liver, or removal of an appendage, leaves merely person minus liver, or person minus arm, removal of explicit memory leaves only mind minus explicit memory.
منابع مشابه
تأثیر فعالیت های بدنی منتخب بر مهارتهای ادراکی-حرکتی کودکان با ناتوانی های یادگیری عصبی- روان شناختی تحولی پیش از دبستان
Objective: One of the most common neurological disorders in pre-school children is neuropsychological disabilities. Disorders in performing perceptual motor movements (activities) are among the signs of this disorder in children. This study aimed to find out the effect of the selected physical activities on perceptual motor abilities in preschool children with neuropsychological disabilities. ...
متن کاملبررسی عوارض عصبی- روانی پرکلرواتیلن در شاغلین خشکشوییها
Neuropsychological Effects of “Perchloroethylene” on Exposed Dry Cleaning Workers Pouryaghoub Gh1, Sadeghniiat Haghighi Kh1, Sarreshtahdar H2 1 Dept of Occupational Medicine, School of Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran 2 Occupational Health Unit, Deputy of Health Services, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran Corresponding Author’s Address: Dept of Occ...
متن کاملP1: A Review of Neuropsychological Function in Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) with Substantial Substance Use Comorbidity
Neuropsychological approach tries to link behavior with brain functions. One of the structural changes and functional disorders that is, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). This impaired memory function, learning, emotional processing and cognitive and structural changes in the brain. Various aspects of neuropsychological function have been reported to be abnormal in (PTSD); however, the maj...
متن کاملEffect of Environment Enrichment (SPARK Perceptual-Motor Exercises) on the Improvement of Neurocognitive Functions in Children with Developmental Coordination Disorder
Introduction: Developmental Coordination Disorder (DCD) is a serious childhood disorder that causes social, emotional, cognitive, and motor difficulties for children. Accordingly, the current study aimed to examine the effect of perceptual-motor training on the improvement of neurocognitive functions in children with DCD. Materials and Methods: Twenty children were selected through simple rando...
متن کاملNeurofeedback Training versus Perceptual-Motor Exercises Interventions in Visual Attention for Children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder: A Randomized Controlled Trial
Introduction: Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is one of the most common childhood psychiatric disorders which is characterized by poor attention and subsequently lower learning capacities comparing with normal children. The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness of neurofeedback and perceptual-motor exercises as two common non-pharmacological treatments on visual...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید
ثبت ناماگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید
ورودعنوان ژورنال:
- Cortex; a journal devoted to the study of the nervous system and behavior
دوره 39 1 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2003